Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription Access

An experiment to refute the likelihood of cellulose carboxylation.

R M Hedges, Christopher Bronk Ramsey, Klinken J van

Abstract


To test the hypothesis that cellulose in linen can be carboxylated at high temperatures in the presence of CO (sub 2) , water and silver, we heated two aliquots of cellulose extracted from old wood in glass ampoules, adding Ag powder to one to test its potential action as a catalyst for the carboxylation reaction. AMS measurement of the heated aliquots showed no statistically significant difference in (super 14) C content from the "uncarboxylated" cellulose. We conclude that carboxylation is not a systematic source of error in the dating of cellulose-containing materials such as the linen in the Shroud of Turin.

Keywords


carboxylation;silver;cellulose;polysaccharides;carbohydrates;temperature;water;accuracy;errors;archaeology;accelerator mass spectroscopy;mass spectroscopy;spectroscopy;metals;experimental studies;organic compounds;methods;wood;C 14;carbon;isotopes;radioactive isotopes;carbon dioxide;absolute age

Full Text:

PDF