Conservation narratives and conflicts over protected areas in post-socialist Romania
Abstract
Environmental protection is never a controversy-free endeavor. Conflicts arise over land ownership, use, and access. Political ecologists have paid extensive attention to protected areas, especially in relation to power, rights, and marginalized peoples. This article draws on political ecology to examine a new proposed national park in the context of post-communism and neoliberalization in Romania. Using mixed-methods (semi-structured interviews, questionnaires, and participant observation), this research investigates conservation narratives as articulated by different actors (environmental non-governmental organizations, local decision-makers, and local community members) with various levels of involvement in the proposed national park. Three chief narratives can be observed pertaining to tourism, restrictions, and deforestation. These narratives are embedded in the history and socio-economic context of the area, but also reveal the agendas of different actors regarding landscape values. Assessing these narratives, this research reveals how actors position themselves and the points of contention among the different actors in the brewing conflict that the national park represents.
Keywords: Political ecology, conservation, conflict, power
Full Text:
PDFReferences
Adams, W.M. 2017. Sleeping with the enemy? Biodiversity conservation, corporations and the green economy. Journal of Political Ecology 24: 243–257.
Ambinakudige, S. 2011. National Parks, coffee and NTFPs: the livelihood capabilities of Adivasis in Kodagu, India. Journal of Political Ecology 18: 1–10.
Andonova, L. 2005. The Europeanization of environmental policy in Central and Eastern Europe. In Frank Schimmelfenning and Ulrich Sedelmeier (eds.). The Europeanization of Central and Eastern Europe. New York: Cornell University Press.
Bauer, N., M. Vasile and M. Mondini. 2018. Attitudes towards nature, wilderness and protected areas: a way to sustainable stewardship in the South-Western Carpathians. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 61(5–6): 857–877.
Bixler, R.P. 2013. The political ecology of local environmental narratives: power, knowledge, and mountain caribou conservation. Journal of Political Ecology 20(1): 273–285.
Blavascunas, E. 2014. When foresters reterritorialize the periphery: Post-socialist forest politics in Białowiez˙a, Poland. Journal of Political Ecology 21(1): 475–492.
Bouriaud, L. 2005. Causes of illegal logging in Central and Eastern Europe. Small-Scale Forest Economics, Management and Policy 4(3): 269–291.
Bouriaud, L. and M. Marzano. 2015. Conservation, extraction and corruption: Is sustainable forest management possible in Romania? In E. Gilberthorpe and G. Hilson (eds.). Natural resource extraction and indigenous livelihoods: development challenges in an era of globalization. Farnham: Ashgate.
Bratman, G.N., J.P. Hamilton and G.C. Daily. 2012. The impacts of nature experience on human cognitive function and mental health. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 1249(1): 118–136.
Braun, V. and V. Clarke. 2006. Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology 3(2): 77–101.
Bridge, G., J. McCarthy and T. Perreault. 2015. Editors' introduction. In G. Bridge, J. McCarthy, and T. Perreault (eds.). The Routledge handbook of political ecology. New York: Routledge. Pp. 3-18.
Brockington, D. 2004. Community conservation, inequality and injustice: myths of power in protected area management. Conservation and Society 2(2): 411–428.
Brown, J.C. and M. Purcell. 2005. There's nothing inherent about scale: political ecology, the local trap, and the politics of development in the Brazilian Amazon. Geoforum 36: 607–624.
Buckley, R. 2011. Tourism and environment. Annual Review of Environment and Resources 36(1): 397–416.
Büscher, B. 2012. Inverted commons: Africa's nature in the global imagination. In D. Münster, U. Münster and S. Dorondel (eds.) Fields and forests: ethnographic perspectives on environmental globalization. Munich: Rachel Carson Centre. Pp. 31–37.
Byrne, J. and J. Wolch 2009. Nature, race, and parks: past research and future directions for geographic research. Progress in Human Geography 33(6): 743–765.
Campbell, L.M. 2007. Local conservation practice and global discourse: a political ecology of sea turtle conservation. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 97(2): 313–334.
Cortés-Vázquez, J. 2014. A natural life: neo-rurals and the power of everyday practices in protected areas. Journal of Political Ecology 21: 493–515.
Cotoi, C. 2017. The making of a national park: ruins of nature and history in Northern Dobrudja. East European Politics and Societies 31(3): 596–614.
Cundill, G., J.C. Bezerra, A. De Vos and N. Ntingana. 2017. Beyond benefit sharing: place attachment and the importance of access to protected areas for surrounding communities. Ecosystem Services 28: 140–148.
Dorondel, S. 2007. Ethnicity, state, and access to natural resources in Southeast Europe: the Rudari case. In S. Serban (ed.). Transborder identities: the Romanian-speaking population in Bulgaria. Bucharest: Paideia.
Dorondel, S. 2016. Disrupted landscapes: state, peasants, and the politics of land in post socialist Romania. New York: Pergamon.
Elmhirst, R. 2011. Migrant pathways to resource access in Lampung's political forest: gender, citizenship and creative conjugality. Geoforum 42(2): 173–183.
European Environment Agency. 2012. Protected areas in Europe — an overview. Copenhagen: EEA. [accessed July 11 2018].
Fletcher, R. 2010. Neoliberal environmentality: towards a poststructuralist political ecology of the conservation debate. Conservation and Society 8(3): 171–181.
Haenn, N., E. Olson, J. Martinez-Reyes, and L. Durand. 2014. Introduction: between capitalism, the state, and the grassroots: Mexico′s contribution to a global conservation debate. Conservation and Society 12(2): 111–119.
Hansson, S. and F. Trabelsi. 2017. "Romerna är romer och vi är rudari" En kvalitativ studie om kvinnliga EU-migranters identitetsuppfattningar. Sweden: Jönköping University.
Hitchins, K. 2014. A concise history of Romania. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Hoffman, A. 2009. Shades of green. Stanford, CA: Stanford Social Innovation Review.
Holmes, G. and C. Cavanagh 2016. A review of the social impacts of neoliberal conservation: formations, inequalities, contestations. Geoforum 75: 199–209.
Horowitz, L. 2010 "Twenty years is yesterday": science, multinational mining, and the political ecology of trust in New Caledonia. Geoforum 41(4): 617–626.
Horowitz, L. 2011. Interpreting industry's impacts: micropolitical ecologies of divergent community responses. Development and Change 42(6): 1379–1391.
Igoe, J. and D. Brockington. 2007. Neoliberal conservation: a brief introduction. Conservation and Society 5(4): 432–449.
Ilie, L. 2019. Thousands of Romanians protest against illegal logging, attacks on forest workers. Reuters 3 November [accessed November 20 2019].
Iojă, C. I., M. Pâtroescu, L. Rozylowicz, V.D. Popescu, M. Vergheleţ, M.I. Zotta and M. Felciuc. 2010. The efficacy of Romania's protected areas network in conserving biodiversity. Biological Conservation 143(11): 2468–2476.
Iorio, M. and M. Corsale. 2010. Rural tourism and livelihood strategies in Romania. Journal of Rural Studies 26(2): 152–162.
Jacoby, K. 2001. Crimes against nature: squatters, poachers, thieves and the hidden history of American conservation. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Jones, N., J. McGinlay and P. Dimitrakopoulos. 2017. Improving social impact assessment of protected areas: a review of the literature and directions for future research. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 64: 1–7.
Kathmann, F., A. Ciutea, I.-A. Biris, P.L. Ibisch and V. Sălăgeanu. 2017. Potential primary forests map of Romania. Bucharest.: Greenpeace. [accessed May 30 2019].
Kay, K. 2014. Europeanization through biodiversity conservation: Croatia's bid for EU accession and the Natura 2000 designation process. Geoforum 54: 80–90.
Kelly, A. 2011. Conservation practice as primitive accumulation. Journal of Peasant Studies 38(4): 683–701.
Keulartz, J. 2009. European nature conservation and restoration policy - Problems and perspectives. Restoration Ecology 17(4): 446–450.
King, B. 2010. Conservation geographies in Sub-Saharan Africa: the politics of national parks, community conservation and peace parks. Geography Compass 4(1): 14–27.
Kiss, A. 2004. Is community-based ecotourism a good use of biodiversity conservation funds? Trends in Ecology and Evolution 19(5): 232–237.
Langholz, J. and J. Lassoie. 2001. Perils and promise of privately owned protected areas. BioScience 51(12): 1079–1085.
Măntescu, L. and M. Vasile. 2009. Property reforms in rural Romania and community-based forests. Sociologie Românească VII(2): 95–113.
McGrath, S. 2019. Romania forest murder as battle over logging turns violent. BBC News 21 October [accessed November 1 2019].
Ministerul Apelor și Pădurilor. 2019. Catalogul naţional al pădurilor virgine şi cvasivirgine din România. Bucharest: Ministerul Apelor și Pădurilor. [accessed May 30 2019].
Mombeshora, S. and S. Le Bel. 2009. Parks-people conflicts: the case of Gonarezhou National Park and the Chitsa community in South-East Zimbabwe. Biodiversity and Conservation 18(10): 2601–2623.
Neumann, R.P. 2015. Nature conservation. In T. Perreault, G. Bridge and J. McCarthy (eds.). The Routledge handbook of political ecology. New York: Routledge. Pp. 391-405.
Neumann, R.P. 2001. Disciplining peasants in Tanzania: from state violence to self-surveillance in wildlife conservation. In N. Peluso and M.J. Watts (eds.). Violent environments. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press. Pp. 305-327
Neumann, R.P. 2009. Political ecology: theorizing scale. Progress in Human Geography 33(3): 398–406.
Overton, J. 1996. Making a world of difference: essays on tourism, culture and development in Newfoundland. St. John's, Newfoundland: Institute of Social and Economic Research.
Petrova, S. 2014. Contesting forest neoliberalization: recombinant geographies of "illegal" logging in the Balkans. Geoforum 55: 13–21.
Pietrzyk-Kaszyńska, A., J. Cent, M. Grodzińska-Jurczak and M. Szymańska. 2012. Factors influencing perception of protected areas: the case of Natura 2000 in Polish Carpathian communities. Journal for Nature Conservation 20(5): 284–292.
Pretty, J. and D. Smith. 2004. Social capital in biodiversity conservation and management. Conservation Biology 18(3): 631-638.
Pullin, A., M. Bangpan, S. Dalrymple, K. Dickson, N. Haddaway, J. Healey, H. Hauari, N. Hockley, J.P.G. Jones, T. Knight, C. Vigurs, and S. Oliver. 2013. Human well-being impacts of terrestrial protected areas. Environmental Evidence 2(19): 1–41.
Radel, C. 2012. Gendered livelihoods and the politics of socio-environmental identity: women's participation in conservation projects in Calakmul, Mexico. Gender, Place and Culture 19(1): 61–82.
Robbins, P. 2012. Political ecology: a critical introduction. Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell.
Roth, R. 2004. On the colonial margins and in the global hotspot: people-park conflicts in highland Thailand. Asia Pacific Viewpoint 45(1): 1–32.
Salafsky, N. and E. Wollenberg. 2000. Linking livelihoods and conservation: a conceptual framework and scale for assessing the integration of human needs and biodiversity. World Development 28(8): 1421–1438.
Sen, A. and S. Pattanaik. 2017. How can traditional livelihoods find a place in contemporary conservation politics debates in India? Understanding community perspectives in Sundarban, West Bengal. Journal of Political Ecology 24: 861–880.
Sodhi, N., T.M. Lee, C. Sekercioglu, E. Webb, D. Prawiradilaga, D. Lohman, N.E. Pierce, A.C. Diesmos, C. Arvin, R. Madhu and P. Ehrlich. 2010. Local people value environmental services provided by forested parks. Biodiversity and Conservation 19(4): 1175–1188.
Sodikoff, G. 2009. The low-wage conservationist: biodiversity and perversities of value in Madagascar. American Anthropologist 111(4): 443-455.
Staddon, C. 2009. Towards a critical political ecology of human-forest interactions: collecting herbs and mushrooms in a Bulgarian locality. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 34(2): 161–176.
Stahl, J. 2010. Rent from the land: a political ecology of postsocialist rural transformation. London: Anthem Press.
Vaccaro, I., O. Beltran and P.A. Paquet. 2013. Political ecology and conservation policies: some theoretical genealogies. Journal of Political Ecology 20: 255–272.
Vasile, M. 2008. Nature conservation, conflict and discourses on forest management: communities and protected areas in Meridional Carpathians. Sociologie Românească, (3–4): 87–100.
Walentowski, H., E.D. Schulze, M. Teodosiu, O. Bouriaud, A. von Heßberg, H. Bußler L. Baldauf, I. Schulze, J. Wäldchen, R. Böcker, S. Herzog, and W. Schulze. 2013. Sustainable forest management of Natura 2000 sites: a case study from a private forest in the Romanian Southern Carpathians. Annals of Forest Research 56(1): 217–245.
Walker, P. and L. Fortmann. 2003. Whose landscape? A political ecology of the “exurban†Sierra. Cultural Geographies 10(4): 469–491.
West, P., J. Igoe and D. Brockington. 2006. Parks and peoples: the social impact of protected areas. Annual Review of Anthropology 35(1): 251–277.
Yakusheva, N. 2017. Parks, policies and people: nature conservation governance in post-socialist EU countries. Ph.D. dissertation. Sweden: Södertörns Högskola.
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.2458/v27i1.23481
Copyright (c) 2020 Marie Louise Aastrup
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.