REDD+ as a tool for state territorialization: managing forests and people in Laos
Abstract
This article analyzes the Reduction of Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation (REDD+) policy process, through the lens of state territorialization in the Lao People's Democratic Republic (Laos). It explores the motivations, mechanisms and strategies that drive REDD+ policy design and its implementation in the country. The provinces selected for REDD+ activities within the Emission Reduction (ER) Program, as well as the various REDD+ pilot projects are located in the north, where shifting cultivation is widespread, but where the potential for REDD+ to address deforestation and carbon sequestration is not optimal. The provinces with high carbon sequestration potential and high rates of deforestation are not part of the ER Program due to development investment projects and political sensitivity in those areas. REDD+ acts as a tool for state territorialization in a number of ways, including: (i) by targeting the areas where shifting cultivation is widely practiced, aiming to regulate village forest uses and users, (ii) by protecting state political, economic and development goals and strategies, by leaving the profitable large-scale drivers of deforestation unaddressed, including large-scale land investments, hydropower, infrastructure and mining development, and finally (iii) by providing additional motives, tools and discourses for state territorialization, including funding, technologies and the narratives that support it. I highlight, however, that REDD+ is not the sole reason for state territorial politics and practices. Rather, the instrument is layered over previous histories of colonial and post-colonial territorialization processes, continuing a similar logic, rhetoric and management practices. The REDD+ design and its technical orientation, however, appear to provide additional motives, as well as a new pool of resources, technical assistance and modern technologies that intensify the practice and politics of state territoriality in Laos.
Keywords: Laos, REDD+, state territorialization, forest politics, drivers of deforestation
Full Text:
PDFReferences
Alden Wily, L. 2012. Looking back to see forward: the legal niceties of land theft in land rushes. The Journal of Peasant Studies 39(3-4): 751-775.
Angelsen, A. (with M. Brockhaus, M. Kanninen, E. Sills, W.D. Sunderlin and S. Wertz-Kanounniko (eds.). 2009. Realising REDD+: national strategy and policy options. Bogor: CIFOR.
Angelsen, A. 2008. (ed.). Moving ahead with REDD issues, options and implications. Bogor: CIFOR.
Baird, I.G. 2010. The Hmong come to Southern Laos: local responses and the creation of racialized boundaries. Hmong Studies Journal 11: 1-38.
Baird, I.G. 2011. Turning land into capital, turning people into labour: primitive accumulation and the arrival of large-scale economic land concessions in the Lao People's Democratic Republic. New Proposals: Journal of Marxism and Interdisciplinary Inquiry 5(1): 10-26.
Baird, I.G. 2015. Translocal assemblages and the circulation of the concept of "indigenous peoples" in Laos. Political Geography 46: 54–64.
Baird, I.G. and B. Shoemaker. 2007. Unsettling experiences: internal resettlement and international aid agencies in Laos. Development and Change 38: 865-888.
Barney, K. 2008. China and the production of forestlands in Laos: a political ecology of transnational enclosure. In J. Nevins and N.L. Peluso (eds.). Taking Southeast Asia to market: commodities, nature, and people in the neoliberal age. Cornell University Press. Pp. 91-107.
Barney, K. 2009. Laos and the making of a 'relational' resource frontier. The Geographical Journal 175: 146-159.
Barney, K. 2014. Ecological knowledge and the making of plantation concession territories in Southern Laos. Conservation and Society 12(4): 352-363.
Bassett, T.J. and D. Gautier. 2014. Regulation by territorialization: the political ecology of conservation & development territories. EchoGéo 29.
Batterbury S.P.J. 2018. Political ecology. In Castree N., M. Hulme and J. Proctor (eds.). The companion to environmental studies. London: Routledge. Pp. 439-442.
Brockhaus, M. and M. Di Gregorio. 2014. National REDD+ policy networks: from cooperation to conflict. Ecology and Society 19(4): 14.
Broegaard, R.B., T. Vongvisouk and O. Mertz. 2017. Contradictory land use plans and policies in Laos: tenure security and the threat of exclusion. World Development 89: 170-189.
Bryant, R. 1998. Power, knowledge and political ecology in the third world: a review. Progress in Physical Geography 22(1): 79-94.
Bryant, R. (ed.). 2015. The international handbook of political ecology. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.
Cole, R., G. Wong, M. Brockhaus, M. Moeliono and M. Kallio. 2017. Objectives, ownership and engagement in Lao PDR's REDD+ policy landscape. Geoforum 83: 91–100.
Corbera, E. and H. Schroeder. 2011. Governing and Implementing REDD+. Environmental Science & Policy 14: 89–99.
Cramb R.A., C.J. Pierce Colfer, W. Dressler, P. Laungaramsri, Q.T. Le, E. Mulyoutami, N.L. Peluso and R.L. Wadley. 2009. Swidden transformations and rural livelihoods in Southeast Asia. Human Ecology 37(3): 323-346.
Creak, S. and K. Barney. Forthcoming. Party-state governance and rule in Laos. Journal of Contemporary Asia. Manuscript ID: RJOC-2017-0281.R1
DoF (Department of Forestry). 2010 Readiness Preparation Proposal (R-Pp) Lao PDR. Vientiane, Lao PDR: Forest Carbon Partnership Facility (FCPF) of the World Bank and Department of Forestry, Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry.
Dressler, W.H, D. Wilson, J. Clendenning, R. Cramb, R. Keenan, S. Mahanty, T.B. Bruun, O. Mertz and R.D. Lasco. 2016. The impact of swidden decline on livelihoods and ecosystem services in Southeast Asia: a review of the evidence from 1990 to 2015. Ambio 46: 291-310.
Dressler, W.H., S. Mahanty, J. Clendenning and P. To. 2015. Rearticulating governance through carbon in the Lao PDR? Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy. 33(5): 1265-1283.
Ducourtieux, O., J.R. Laffort and S. Sacklokham. 2005. Land policy and farming practices in Laos. Development and Change 36(3): 499-526.
Dwyer, M. 2007. Turning land into capital: a review of recent research on land concessions for investment in Lao PDR (Vol. 1 and 2). Unpublished Reports. Vientiane: Land Issues Working Group.
Dwyer, M. and M. Ingalls. 2015. REDD at the crossroads: choices and tradeoffs for 2015–2020 in Laos. Working Paper 17. Bogor: CIFOR.
Dwyer, M., M. Ingalls and I.G. Baird. 2016. The security exception: development and militarization in Laos's protected areas. Geoforum 69: 207–217.
Ece, M., J. Murombedzi and J. Ribot. 2018. Disempowering democracy: local representation in community and carbon forestry in Africa. Conservation and Society 15(4): 357-370.
ERPD (Emission Reductions Program Document). 2018. Forest Carbon Partnership Facility (FCPF) Carbon Fund Emission Reductions Program Document (ER-PD). Promoting REDD+ through governance, forest landscapes & livelihoods in Northern Lao PDR. 26 March, 2018.
Evans, G. 2002. A short history of Laos: the land in between. Sydney: Allen & Unwin.
Evrard, O. and Y. Goudineau. 2004. Planned resettlement, unexpected migrations and cultural trauma in Laos. Development and Change 35(5): 937–962.
FCPF (Forest Carbon Partnership Facility). 2015. Carbon Fund ER-PIN (Emission Reductions Program Idea Note (ER-PIN). Lao PDR: Promoting REDD+ through Governance, Forest landscapes and Livelihoods in Northern Lao PDR.
Fletcher, R., W.H. Dressler, B. Büscher and Z.R. Anderson. 2016. Questioning REDD+ and the future of market-based conservation. Conservation Biology 30: 673–675.
Fox, J. 2002. Siam Mapped and mapping in Cambodia: boundaries, sovereignty, and indigenous conceptions of space. Society and Natural Resources 15(1): 65-78.
Fox, J., Y. Fujita, D. Ngidang, N.L. Peluso, L. Potter, N. Sakuntaladewi, J. Sturgeon and D. Thomas. 2009. Policies, political-economy, and swidden in Southeast Asia. Hum Ecology 37: 305–322.
Ingalls M.L. and M.B. Dwyer. 2016. Missing the forest for the trees? Navigating the trade-offs between mitigation and adaptation under REDD. Climatic Change 136(2): 353-366.
Katz, L. 2010. Red tape and gridlock. Canadian Journal of Law and Jurisprudence 23(1): 99-123.
Kelly, A.B. and N.L. Peluso. 2015. Frontiers of commodification: state lands and their formalization. Society and Natural Resources 28(5): 473-495.
Kenney-Lazar, M. 2011. Dispossession, semi-proletarianization, and enclosure: primitive accumulation and the land grab in Laos. Paper presented at the International conference on Global Land Grabbing, 6-8-April 2011. Available at: https://www.future-agricultures.org/wp-content/uploads/pdf-archive/Miles%20Kenney-Lazar.pdf (Accessed July 2019)
Kenney-Lazar, M. 2013. Shifting cultivation in Laos: Transitions in policy and perspective. Report. Sector Working Group-Agriculture and Rural Development (SWG-ARD).
Kenney-Lazar, M. 2017. Governing dispossession: relational land grabbing in Laos. Annals of the American Association of Geographers 108(3): 679-694.
Kingsbury, D. 2017. Politics in contemporary Southeast Asia. London: Routledge.
Koch, S. 2017. The struggle over Lao PDR's forests: new opportunities for improved forest governance? Pacific Geographies 47(January/February): 4-13.
Lavers, T. 2012. 'Land grab' as development strategy? The political economy of agricultural investment in Ethiopia. The Journal of Peasant Studies 39(1): 105-132.
Lavers, T. and F. Boamah. 2016. The impact of agricultural investments on state capacity: a comparative analysis of Ethiopia and Ghana. Geoforum 72: 94-103.
Lestrelin, G. 2009. Changing lives, changing nature(s): socio-environmental transitions in the uplands of the Lao PDR, PhD dissertation. Durham University.
Lestrelin, G. 2010. Land degradation in the Lao PDR: discourses and policy. Land Use Policy 27(2): 424–439.
Lestrelin, G., J-C. Castella and J. Bourgoin. 2012. Territorialising sustainable development: the politics of land-use planning in Laos. Journal of Contemporary Asia 42(4): 581-602.
Lund, C. 2011. Fragmented sovereignty: land reform and dispossession in Laos. Journal of Peasant Studies 38(4): 885-905.
Lund, C. and N.F. Rachman. 2018. Indirect recognition: frontiers and territorialization around Mount Halimun-Salak National Park, Indonesia. World Development 101: 417–428.
Lund, J.F., E. Sungusia, M.B. Mabele and A. Scheba. 2017. Promising change, delivering continuity: REDD as conservation fad. World Development 89: 124-139.
MAF (Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry) 2018. FCPF Emission Reductions Program Document (ER-PD) of Lao PDR. Promoting REDD+ through Governance, Forest Landscapes and Livelihoods in Northern Lao PDR. Forest Carbon Partnership Facility. (Accessed February 2019)
Mahanty, S., A. Bradley and S. Milne. 2015. The forest carbon commodity chain in Cambodia's voluntary carbon market. In Milne, S. and S. Mahanty (eds.). Conservation and development in Cambodia: exploring frontiers of change in nature, state and society. New York: Routledge. Pp. 177–200.
Mahanty, S., W.H. Dressler, S. Milne and C. Filer. 2013. Unravelling property relations around forest carbon. Singapore Journal of Tropical Geography 34: 188–205.
McElwee, P.D. 2016. Doing REDD+ work in Vietnam: will the new carbon focus bring equity to forest management? In Fiske, S. and S. Paladino (eds.). The carbon fix: global equity and the new environmental regime. Berkeley: Left Coast Press. Pp. 184-200.
McElwee, P.D., Nguyen Hai Van, Nguyen Viet Dung, Tran Huu Nghi, Le Thi Van Hue, Nghiem Phuong Tuyen and Vu Dieu Huong. 2016. Using REDD+ policy to facilitate climate adaptation at the local level: synergies and challenges in Vietnam. Forests 8: 1.
Moore, P., M. Pholsena, K. Phommachanh and R. Glémet. 2013. Review of statutory and customary law in the Xe Champhone Ramsar Site, Lao PDR: implications for a rights-based approach to conservation. Vientiane: IUCN.
Mustalahti, I. and D.T. Tassa. 2012. Analysis of three crucial elements of REDD+ in participatory forest management. Scandinavian Journal of Forestry Research 27(2): 200–209.
Mustalahti, I., M. Cramm, S. Ramcilovic-Suominen and Y.T. Tegegne. 2017. Resources and rules of the game: participation of civil society in REDD+ and FLEGT-VPA processes in Lao PDR. Forests 8, 50.
Myers, R., A.M. Larson, A. Ravikumar, L.F. Kowler, A. Yang and T. Trench. 2018. Messiness of forest governance: how technical approaches suppress politics in REDD+ and conservation projects. Global Environmental Change 50: 214-324.
Pasgaard, M. and O. Mertz. 2016. Desirable qualities of REDD+ projects not considered in decisions of project locations. Environmental Research Letters 11: 114014.
Peluso, N.L. and P. Vandergeest. 2001. Genealogies of the political forest and customary rights in Indonesia, Malaysia and Thailand. The Journal of Asian Studies 60(3):761-812.
Peluso, N.L. and P. Vandergeest. 2011. Political ecologies of war and forests: counterinsurgencies and the making of national natures. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 101(3): 587-608.
Peluso, N.L. 2005. Seeing property in land use: local territorializations in West Kalimantan, Indonesia. Geografisk Tidsskrift, Danish Journal of Geography 105(1): 1-15.
Phelps, J., E.L. Webb and A. Agrawal. 2010. Does REDD threaten to recentralize forest governance? Science 328(5976): 312–313.
Phraxayavong, W. 2009. History of aid to Laos: motivations and impacts. Thailand: Silkworm Books.
PRAP (Provincial REDD+ Action Plan) 2017. PARP for Houaphan Province, LAO PDR. Draft 2 Feb. 2017.
Ramcilovic-Suominen, S. and I. Nathan, I. forthcoming. REDD+ in policy translation: discourses and storylines from global to village level in Laos. Journal of Political Ecology.
Ramcilovic-Suominen, S., M. Lovric and I. Mustalahti. 2019. Mapping policy actor networks and their interests in the FLEGT Voluntary Partnership Agreement in Lao PDR. World Development 118: 128–148.
Rasmussen, M.B. and C. Lund. 2018. Reconfiguring frontier spaces: territorialization and resource control. World Development 101: 388–399.
Robbins, P. 2004. Political ecology: a critical introduction. Oxford: Blackwell.
Sack, R.D. 1986. Human territoriality: its theory and history. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Scott, J.C. 1998. Seeing like a state: how certain schemes to improve the human condition have failed. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Singh, S. 2012. Natural potency and political power: forests and state authority in contemporary Laos. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press.
Smith, H., K. Barney, N. Byron, S. Van Der Meer, S. Phimmavong, R. Keenan and V. Vongkhamsao. 2016. Tree plantations in Lao PDR: policy framework and review. Project report. Canberra: ACIAR.
Stern, H.N. and G. Britain. 2007. The economics of climate change: the Stern Review. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Stuart-Fox, M. 1997. A history of Laos. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Stuart-Fox, M. 2005. Politics and reform in Lao People's Democratic Republic. Working Paper 126. Perth: Asia Research Centre, Murdoch University.
Stuart-Fox, M. 2006. The political culture of corruption in the Lao PDR. Asian Studies Review 30(1): 59-75.
Stuart-Fox, M. 1983. Marxism and Theravada Buddhism: the legitimation of political authority in Laos. Pacific Affairs 56: 428-454.
Suhardiman, D. and M. Giordano. 2014. Legal plurality: an analysis of power interplay in Mekong hydropower. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 104(5): 973-988.
Suhardiman, D., O. Keovilignavong and M. Kenney-Lazar. 2019. The territorial politics of land use planning in Laos. Land Use Policy 83: 346–356.
Tacconi, L., S. Mahanty and H. Suich. 2013. The livelihood impacts of Payments for Environmental Services and Implications for REDD+. Society and Natural Resources 26(6): 733-744.
Thomas, I., N. Chorn, D. Braeutigam, S. Thongmanivong, S. Boulidam, T. Phimminit, K. Hurni and C. Hett. 2010. Analysis of land use and forest changes and related driving forces in the Lao PDR. A contribution to the REDD+ Readiness Plan. Department of Forestry.
Thompson, M.C., M. Baruah and E.R. Carr. 2011. Seeing REDD+ as a project of environmental governance. Environmental Science & Policy 14: 100-110.
To, P.X. 2015. State territorialization and illegal logging: the dynamic relationships between practices and images of the state in Vietnam. Critical Asian Studies 47(2): 229-252.
To, P.X., N.B. Treanor and K. Canby. 2017. Impacts of the Laos log and sawnwood export bans: significant reductions in the exports to major markets of Vietnam and China in 2016. Washington DC: Forest Trends.
UNDP (United Nations Development Program). 2011a. People's perspective on access to justice survey in four provinces of Lao PDR. UNDP-Laos.
UNDP (United Nations Development Program). 2011b. Customary law and practice in Lao PDR. New York: UNDP.
Vandergeest, P. 1996. Mapping nature: territorialization of forest rights in Thailand. Society and Natural Resources 9: 159-175.
Vandergeest, P. and A. Unno. 2012. A new extraterritoriality? Aquaculture certification, sovereignty, and empire. Political Geography. 31(6): 358-367.
Vandergeest, P. and N.L. Peluso. 1995. Territorialization and state power in Thailand. Theory and Society 24: 385-426.
Vandergeest, P. and N.L. Peluso. 2006. Empires of forestry: professional forestry and state power in Southeast Asia, Part 1. Environment and History 12: 31–64.
Vongvisouk, T., G. Lestrelin, J-C. Castella, O. Mertz, R.B. Broegaard and S. Thongmanivong. 2016. REDD+ on hold: lessons from an emerging institutional setup in Laos. Asia Pacific Viewpoint 57(3): 393-405.
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.2458/v26i1.23357
Copyright (c) 2019 Sabaheta Ramcilovik-Suominen
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.