The irresistible solution: rationale and risks of extending water limits through desalination in the case of Gotland, Sweden
Abstract
Water resources are under increasing pressure, and there are tensions between increasing demand and the natural limits to potable water supply. Authorities must find solutions that fulfil societal demands without compromising environmental integrity. As one way to counteract water deficits, desalination has evolved as an attractive solution. This technology is contested and associated with a variety of social, environmental and economic consequences; yet it is increasingly used. In Sweden, the technology is rare but recent droughts have spurred interest. On the island of Gotland, where Sweden's first larger desalination plant was inaugurated in 2016, we examine the perceived benefits and drawbacks of desalination as well as the decision-making process that led up to its implementation. Through qualitative analysis of public documents and stakeholder interviews, we identify mechanisms that contributed to desalination becoming a favored solution. We find that it is associated with a number of benefits that are in line with broader development goals, against which its drawbacks are considered to be acceptable or externalized. Desalination extends natural limits to permit development, delaying deeper social and economic restructuring. Rather than arguing against desalination per se, we emphasize the risk of the depoliticization of water supply through technocratic decision-making, the normalization of scarcity and certain technologies, and the urgency that builds around increasing water supply 'at any economic cost.' These tendencies obscure drawbacks, limitations and conflicting interests. They foreclose the questioning of resource intensive development. In order to invoke transformation towards long-term sustainability of Gotland's water supply, policy-makers should seek to diversify their sources of knowledge and encourage more open democratic debate around alternative regional development pathways.
Keywords: desalination, natural limits, water scarcity, Gotland, political ecology, technocracy, depoliticization, normalization
Full Text:
PDFReferences
Anderson, J., S. Bassi, T. Dworak, M. Fergusson, C. Laaser, O. Le Mat, V. Matteiβ and P. Strosser. 2008. Potential impacts of desalination development on energy consumption. Vienna: Institute for European Environmental Policy.
Andersson, C.V. 2018. Allt fler vill dricka avsaltat havsvatten [More and more people want to drink desalinated water]. Sveriges Radio. [accessed August 13 2018]. https://sverigesradio.se/sida/artikel.aspx?programid=83andartikel=6998008
Asp, M., S. Berggreen-Clausen, G. Berglöv, E. Björck, J.E. Mårtensson, L. Nylén, A. Ohlsson, H. Persson and E. Sjökvist. 2015. Framtidens klimat i Gotlands län - enligt RCP-scenarier [Future climate in Gotland region – according to RCP-scenarios]. SMHI Klimatologi report series no 31.
Bakker, K. 2000. Privatizing water, producing scarcity: the Yorkshire drought of 1995. Economic Geography 76(1): 4-27.
Benton, T. and I. Craib. 2010. Philosophy of social science: the philosophical foundations of social thought. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Bowen, G.A. 2009. Document analysis as a qualitative research method. Qualitative Research Journal 9(2): 27-40.
Bryman, A. 2012. Social research methods (4th ed.). Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Cooley, H. and M. Heberger. 2013. Key issues for seawater desalination in California: energy and greenhouse gas emissions. Oakland, CA: Pacific Institute.
Dahlqvist, M., B. Thorsbrink, J. Holgersson, L. Nisell, L. Maxe and M. Gustafsson. 2017. Våtmarker och grundvattenbildning – om möjligheten till ökad kapacitet vid grundvattentäkter på Gotland [Wetlands and ground water formation – on the possibility for increased capacity of groundwater catchement areas on Gotland]. SGU report series No. 2017: 01.
Dickie, P. 2007. Making water: desalination: option or distraction for a thirsty world? Gland: WWF International.
Dryzek, J.S. 2013. The politics of the earth: environmental discourses. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Feitelson, E. and A. Jones. 2014. Global diffusion of XL-capacity seawater desalination. Water Policy 16(6): 1031-1053.
Flyvbjerg, B. 2006. Five misunderstandings about case-study research. Qualitative Inquiry 2(2): 219-245.
Forsyth, T.J. 2001. Critical realism and political ecology. In Lopez, J. and G. Potter (eds.) After postmodernism: an introduction to critical realism. London: Athlone Press. Pp. 146-154.
Forsyth, T.J. 2003. Critical political ecology: the politics of environmental science. London: Routledge.
Fragkou, M.C. and J. McEvoy. 2016. Trust matters: why augmenting water supplies via desalination may not overcome perceptual water scarcity. Desalination 397: 1-8.
Fredelius, A. 2017. Nu avsaltar Öland havsvatten [Now Öland is desalinating sea water]. Dagens Industri [accessed August 13 2018] https://www.nyteknik.se/samhalle/nu-avsaltar-oland-havsvatten-6857517
Geological Survey of Sweden. 2016. Extremt låga grundvattennivåer [Extremely low groundwater levels] [accessed January 15 2017] http://www.sgu.se/om-sgu/nyheter/2016/mars/extremt-laga-grundvattennivaer/
Gezon, L.L. and S. Paulson (eds.). 2005. Political ecology across spaces, scales and social groups. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press.
Ghaffour, N., T.M. Missimer and G.L. Amy. 2013. Technical review and evaluation of the economics of water desalination: current and future challenges for better water supply sustainability. Desalination 309: 197-207.
Gleeson, T., W.M. Alley, D.M. Allen, M.A. Sophocleous, Y. Zhou, M. Taniguchi and J. Van der Steen. 2012. Towards sustainable groundwater use: setting long-term goals, backcasting, and managing adaptively. Ground Water 50(1): 19-26.
Gleick, H. 2003. Global freshwater resources: soft-path solutions for the 21st century. Science 302(5650): 1524-1528.
Gotlands Kommun. 2005. Vattenplan för Gotlands kommun [Water plan for Gotland municipality]. https://www.gotland.se/servlet/GetDoc?meta_id=41892
Gotlands Kommun. 2008. Vision Gotland 2025 - Regionalt utvecklingsprogram för Gotland – RUP [Regional development plan for Gotland]. https://gotland.se/75704
Gotlands Kommun. 2010. Bygg Gotland - Översiktsplan för Gotlands kommun 2010-2025 [Build Gotland – Overview plan for Gotland municipality]. https://www.gotland.se/50630
Greenlee, L.F., D. Lawler, B.D. Freeman, B. Marrot and P. Moulin. 2009. Reverse osmosis desalination: water sources, technology, and today's challenges. Water Research 43(9): 2317-2348.
Kaika, M. 2006. The political ecology of water scarcity: the 1989–1991 Athenian drought. In N. Heynen, M. Kaika and E. Swyngedouw (eds.) In the nature of cities: urban political ecology and the politics of urban metabolism. London: Routledge. Pp. 150-164.
Kallis, G. 2008. Droughts. Annual Review of Environment and Resources 33: 85-118.
Kenis, A. and M. Lievens. 2014. Searching for 'the political' in environmental politics. Environmental Politics 23(4): 531-548.
Knights, D., MacGill, I. and R. Passey. 2007. The sustainability of desalination plants in Australia: is renewable energy the answer? Paper presented at the OzWater Conference, Sydney, Australia.
Koontz, B. and T. Hatfield. 2016. The permitting of desalination facilities: a sustainability perspective. Journal of Environmental Health 79(4): 28-32.
Lior, N. 2017. Sustainability as the quantitative norm for water desalination impacts. Desalination 401: 99-111.
Länsstyrelsen Gotland. 2018. Regional vattenförsörjningsplan [Regional water supply plan]. http://www.lansstyrelsen.se/Gotland/Sv/miljo-och-klimat/vatten-och-vattenanvandning/Pages/vattenforsorjningsplan.aspx
Machin, A. and G. Smith. 2014. Ends, means, beginnings: environmental technocracy, ecological deliberation or embodied disagreement. Ethical Perspectives 21(1): 47-72.
March, H. 2015. The politics, geography, and economics of desalination: a critical review. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Water 2(3): 231-243.
Martinsson, M. 1997. Våtmarker på Gotland, Del 1 [Wetlands on Gotland, Part 1]. Länsstyrelsen i Gotland, Livsmiljöenheten report No. 8: 1997. https://www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:912823/FULLTEXT01.pdf
McEvoy, J. 2015. Can the adoption of desalination technology lead to aquifer preservation? A case study of a sociotechnical water system in Baja California Sur, Mexico. Water 7(10): 5224-5238.
Meerganz von Medeazza, G. 2005. "Direct" and socially-induced environmental impacts of desalination. Desalination 85(1): 57-70.
Miller, J.E. 2003. Review of water resources and desalination technologies. Sandia National Labs Unlimited release report SAND-2003-0800.
https://prod.sandia.gov/techlib-noauth/access-control.cgi/2003/030800.pdf
Molle, F., P. Mollinga and R. Meinzen-Dick. 2008. Water, politics and development: introducing water alternatives. Water Alternatives 1(1): 1-6.
Otero, I., Kallis, G., Aguilar, R. and V. Ruiz. 2011. Water scarcity, social power and the production of an elite suburb: the political ecology of water in Matadepera, Catalonia. Ecological Economics 70(7): 1297-1308.
Region Gotland. 2014. Långsiktig plan för VA-utbyggnad på Gotland 2014-2022 [Long-term plan for expansion of water and sewage on Gotland]. https://www.gotland.se/52725
Region Gotland. 2017. Gotland i siffror [Gotland in figures]. http://www.gotland.se/64224
Region Gotland. 2018. Bräckvattenverk i Kvarnåkershamn [Desalination plant in Kvarnåkershamn] [Accessed August 8 2018] https://www.gotland.se/93575
Region Gotland. n.d.-a. Gotlands grundvatten och dricksvatten - förutsättningar och utmaningar inför framtiden [Gotland's groundwater and drinking water – preconditions and challenges for the future]. https://www.gotland.se/94272
Region Gotland. n.d.-b. Information om Bräckvattenverket i Herrvik på Gotland - först i Sverige [Information about the desalination plant in Herrvik on Gotland – first in Sweden]. http://www.gotland.se/91546
Region Gotland Teknikförvaltningen. 2016a. Förstudierapport Visby framtida vattenförsörjning [Pre-study report Visby future water supply] (Unpublished).
Region Gotland Teknikförvaltningen. 2016b. Översyn av VA-planens del A. Verksamhetsplan. [Overview of water and sewage plan part A. Operational plan]. https://www.gotland.se/90147
Robbins: 2002. Obstacles to a First World political ecology? Looking near without looking up. Environment and Planning A 34(8): 1509-1513.
Robbins: 2011. Political ecology: a critical introduction (2nd ed.). Chichester: Wiley.
Rosborg, I. 2015. Drinking water minerals and mineral balance. Cham: Springer.
Santos Pereira, S., Cordery, I. and I. Iacovides. 2009. Coping with water scarcity: addressing the challenges. Berlin: Springer.
Sayer, A. 2000. Realism and social science. London: Sage.
Scheba, S. and A. Scheba. 2018. Desalination as emergency fix: tracing the drought–desalination assemblage in South Africa. In J. Williams and E. Swyngedouw (eds.). Tapping the oceans: seawater desalination and the political ecology of water. Cheltenham : Edward Elgar. Pp. 98-120.
Schiffler, M. 2004. Perspectives and challenges for desalination in the 21st century. Desalination 65: 1-9.
Statistics Sweden. 2013. Land use in Sweden, 6th edition. Report no MI03BR1301. http://www.scb.se/Statistik/_Publikationer/MI0803_2010A01B_BR_00_MI03BR1301.pdf
Statistics Sweden. 2019. Vattenuttag och vattenanvändning i Sverige [Water withdrawal and water use in Sweden] [Accessed January 24 2019] http://www.scb.se/mi0902
Steffen, W., K. Richardson, J. Rockström, S.E. Cornell, I. Fetzer, E.M. Bennett, R. Biggs, S.R. Carpenter, W. de Vries, C.A. de Wit, C. Folke, D. Gerten, J. Heinke, G.M. Mace, M. Persson, V. Ramanathan, B. Reyers. and S. Sörlin. 2015. Planetary boundaries: guiding human development on a changing planet. Science 347(6223): 1259855.
Sveriges Radio. 2018. Företagen som förbrukar mest kommunalt vatten [The companies that use the most municipal water] [Accessed January 20 2019] https://sverigesradio.se/sida/artikel.aspx?programid=94andartikel=6372386
SVT. 2018. Norra Europas största bräckvattenverk byggs på Gotland [Northern Europe's largest desalination plant is built on Gotland] [Accessed August 28 2018] https://www.svt.se/nyheter/lokalt/ost/vattenverk-1
Swedish Agency for Economic and Regional Growth. 2011. Tourism in Sweden. http://ec.europa.eu/regional_policy/sources/docgener/evaluation/library/sweden/1110_sweden_tourism_eval_en.pdf
Swyngedouw, E. 2009. The political economy and political ecology of the hydroâ€social cycle. Journal of Contemporary Water Research and Education 42(1): 56-60.
Swyngedouw, E. 2011. Depoliticized environments: the end of nature, climate change and the post-political condition. Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplement 69: 253-274.
Swyngedouw, E. 2013. Into the sea: desalination as hydro-social fix in Spain. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 103(2): 261-270.
Swyngedouw, E. and J. Williams. 2016. From Spain's hydro-deadlock to the desalination fix. Water International 41(1): 54-73.
Usher, M. 2018. Desaliâ€nation: technoâ€diplomacy and hydraulic state restructuring through reverse osmosis membranes in Singapore. Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers 44(1): 110-124.
Williams, J. 2018. Diversification or loading order? Divergent water-energy politics and the contradictions of desalination in southern California. Water Alternatives 11(3): 847-865.
World Water Assessment Programme. 2012. The United Nations world water development report 4, volume 2: Knowledge base. Paris: UNESCO.
Yin, R.K. 2009. Case study research: design and methods (4th ed.). London: Sage.
Zucchetto, J., and A.-M. Jansson. 1985. Resources and society: a systems ecology study of the island of Gotland, Sweden. New York: Springer.
Zarzo, D. and D. Prats. 2018. Desalination and energy consumption. What can we expect in the near future? Desalination 427: 1-9.
Zwarteveen, M.Z. and R. Boelens. 2014. Defining, researching and struggling for water justice: some conceptual building blocks for research and action. Water International 39(2): 143-158.
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.2458/v26i1.22984
Copyright (c) 2019 Sophia Speckhahn, Ellinor Isgren
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.