Three implications of political ontology for the political ecology of conservation
Abstract
Within political ecology, an important and timely critique has emerged which questions ontology and the nature of reality. This turn to ontology has been expressed in a new and influential paradigm, Political Ontology. In this article, I interrogate the politics of three tenets that seem central to this ontological turn within a political ecology of conservation context: (a) the insistence on the local, Indigenous and homogeneous subject and its corollary, the homogeneous Modern, Western subject; (b) the hegemony of the (green) neoliberal project, and (c) the incommensurability of non-modern and Western ontologies. I base my arguments on two case studies of resistance and/or struggle against green and un-green grabbing, the Skouries gold mine in Greece and the Lodge Hill development in England.
Keywords: political ontology, neoliberal nature, conservation, Indigenous, Greece, England
Full Text:
PDFReferences
Acuña, R.M. 2015. The politics of extractive governance: Indigenous peoples and socio-environmental conflicts. The Extractive Industries and Society 2(1): 85-92.
Adams, W.M. 2017. Sleeping with the enemy? Biodiversity conservation, corporations and the green economy. Journal of Political Ecology 24: 244-257.
Apostolopoulou, E. and W.M. Adams. 2015. Neoliberal capitalism and conservation in the cost-crisis era: the dialectics of "green" and "un-green" grabbing in Greece and the UK. Antipode 47(1): 15-35.
Apostolopoulou, E., D. Bormpoudakis, R. Paloniemi, J. Cent, M. Grodzińska-Jurczak, A. Pietrzyk-Kaszyńska and J.D. Pantis. 2014. Governance rescaling and the neoliberalization of nature: the case of biodiversity conservation in four EU countries. International Journal of Sustainable Development and World Ecology 21(6): 481-494.
Blaser, M. 2009. The threat of the Yrmo: the political ontology of a sustainable hunting program. American Anthropologist 111(1): 10-20.
Blaser, M. 2013a. Notes towards a political ontology of 'environmental' conflicts. In Green L. (ed.) Contested ecologies: dialogues in the South on nature and knowledge. Cape Town: HSRC Press. Pp. 13-27.
Blaser, M. 2013b. Ontological conflicts and the stories of peoples in spite of Europe. Current Anthropology 54(5): 547-568.
Bormpoudakis D., J. Tzanopoulos and E. Apostolopoulou. 2019. The rise and fall of biodiversity offsetting in the Lodge Hill large-scale housing development, South East England. Environment and Planning E: Nature and Space. Nov., in press. https://doi.org/10.1177/2514848619884890
Boutet, J.S. 2014. Opening Ungava to industry: a decentring approach to Indigenous history in subarctic Québec, 1937–54. Cultural Geographies 21(1): 79-97.
Büscher, B., S. Sullivan, K. Neves, J. Igoe and D. Brockington. 2012. Towards a synthesized critique of neoliberal biodiversity conservation. Capitalism Nature Socialism 23: 4-30.
Chrepa, E, and S. Nikas. 2018. Kyriakos Mitsotakis has big investment plans for Greece. Bloomberg 17 October. [accessed 28 August 2019].
https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-10-17/greek-pm-wannabe-says-unblocking-hellinikon-skouries-a-priority.
De la Cadena, M. 2010. Indigenous cosmopolitics in the Andes: conceptual reflections beyond "politics". Cultural Anthropology 25(2): 334-370.
Defra [Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs]. 2013. Biodiversity offsetting in England Green Paper. [accessed 26 Sept. 2019]. https://consult.defra.gov.uk/biodiversity/biodiversity_offsetting/supporting_documents/20130903Biodiversity%20offsetting%20green%20paper.pdf
Defra [Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs]. 2016. Consultation on biodiversity offsetting in England: Summary of responses. [accessed 26 Sept. 2016].
https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/501240/biodiversity-offsetting-consult-sum-resp.pdf.
Dempsey, J. and D.C. Suarez. 2016. Arrested development? The promises and paradoxes of "selling nature to save it". Annals of the American Association of Geographers 106(3): 653-671.
Department of Environment. 1995. The Thames Gateway Planning Framework (RPG9A). London: HMSO.
Descola, P. 2013. Beyond nature and culture. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Diaz, S., U. Pascual, G. Pataki et al. 2016. Preliminary guide regarding diverse conceptualization of multiple values of nature and its benefits, including biodiversity and ecosystem functions and services. Bonn: Intergovernmental Panel on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services.
Dressler, W.H., W. Smith and M.J. Montefrio. 2018. Ungovernable? The vital natures of swidden assemblages in an upland frontier. Journal of Rural Studies 61: 343-354.
Dunlap, A. 2019. Revisiting the wind energy conflict in Gui'Xhi'Ro/Ãlvaro Obregón: interview with an Indigenous anarchist. Journal of Political Ecology 26(1): 150-166.
Escobar, A. 1996. Construction nature: elements for a post-structuralist political ecology. Futures 28(4): 325-343.
Escobar, A. 1999. After nature: steps to an antiessentialist political ecology. Current Anthropology 40(1): 1-30.
Escobar, A. 2016. Thinking-feeling with the Earth: territorial struggles and the ontological dimension of the epistemologies of the South. AIBR. Revista de AntropologÃa Iberoamericana 11(1): 11-32.
Fukuyama, F. 1992. The end of history and the last man. New York: Free Press.
Goldman, M.J., M.D. Turner and M. Daly. 2018. A critical political ecology of human dimensions of climate change: Epistemology, ontology, and ethics. Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change 9(4): e526.
Granitsas, A. 2013. Greece to approve gold project. Wall Street Journal Feb. 21. [accessed 28 August 2019]. https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424127887323549204578317991953925204.
Hall, S. 2011. The neo-liberal revolution. Cultural Studies 25(6): 705-728.
Herzfeld, M. 2003. Localism and the logic of nationalistic folklore: Cretan reflections. Comparative Studies in Society and History 45: 281-310.
Hewson, C.M. and R.J. Fuller. 2012. Factors potentially affecting the viability and success of biodiversity offsetting to compensate for Nightingale habitat loss. The Nunnery, Thetford: British Trust for Ornithology.
HM Government. 2011. The natural choice: securing the value of nature. [accessed 4 May 2018]. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/the-natural-choice-securing-the-value-of-nature.
Hornborg, A. 2015. The political economy of technofetishism: agency, Amazonian ontologies, and global magic. HAU: Journal of Ethnographic Theory 5(1): 35-57.
Htun, M. and J.P. Ossa. 2013. Political inclusion of marginalized groups: Indigenous reservations and gender parity in Bolivia. Politics, Groups, and Identities 1: 4-25.
Ingold, T. and T. Kurttila. 2000. Perceiving the environment in Finnish Lapland. Body and Society 6(3-4): 183-196.
Kallis, G. 2013. "Extractivism", the Greek way. Greeklish Website, 23 May 2013. [accessed 04 May 2016]. http://greeklish.info/en/greece/environment/33.
Marvier M., P. Kareiva and R. Lalasz. 2012. Conservation in the Anthropocene: beyond solitude and fragility. The Breakthrough Journal 2. https://thebreakthrough.org/journal/issue-2/conservation-in-the-anthropocene. [accessed 28 Sept. 2019].
Kenter, J.O. 2018. IPBES: don't throw out the baby whilst keeping the bathwater; people's values central, not nature's contributions. Ecosystem Services 33(A): 40-43.
Kirsch, S. and D. Mitchell. 2004. The nature of things: dead labor, nonhuman actors, and the persistence of Marxism. Antipode 36(4): 687-705.
Kohn, E. 2015. Anthropology of ontologies. Annual Review of Anthropology 44(1): 311-327.
Kull, C.A., X. Arnauld de Sartre and M. Castro-Larrañaga. 2015. The political ecology of ecosystem services. Geoforum 61: 122-134.
Laurie, N., R. Andolina and S. Radcliffe. 2005. Ethnodevelopment: social movements, creating experts and professionalising Indigenous knowledge in Ecuador. Antipode 37: 470-496.
Maron, M., R.J. Hobbs, A. Moilanen, J.W. Matthews, K. Christie, T.A. Gardner, D.A. Keith, D.B. Lindenmayer and C.A. McAlpine. 2012. Faustian bargains? Restoration realities in the context of biodiversity offset policies. Biological Conservation 155: 141-148.
Martinez-Alier, J., I. Anguelovski, P. Bond, D. Del Bene, F. Demaria, J.F. Gerber, L. Greyl, W. Haas, H. Healy, M. MarÃn-Burgos, G. Ojo, M.F. Porto, L. Rijnhout, B. RodrÃguez-Labajos, J. Spangenberg, L. Temper, R. Warlenius and I. Yánez. 2014. Between activism and science: grassroots concepts for sustainability coined by Environmental Justice Organizations. Journal of Political Ecology 21: 19-60.
McAfee, K. 1999. Selling nature to save it? Biodiversity and green developmentalism. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 17: 133-154.
McCarthy, J. and S. Prudham. 2004. Neoliberal nature and the nature of neoliberalism. Geoforum 35: 275-283.
Moss, S. 2014. Songbirds in decline – a tragedy for Britain's culture, as well as its environment. The Guardian Friday 11 April, available at http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2014/apr/11/nightingale-decline-british-songbirds [accessed 18 November 2015].
Neimark, B., J. Childs, A.J. Nightingale, C.J. Cavanagh, S. Sullivan, T.A. Benjaminsen, S.P.J. Batterbury, S. Koot and W. Harcourt. 2019. Speaking power to "post-truth": critical political ecology and the new authoritarianism. Annals of the American Association of Geographers 109(2): 613-623. Researchgate
Pickard, J. and G. Parker. 2013. Osborne chides cabinet over enterprise zones. Financial Times 26 February. http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/ce481fc0-8036-11e2-aed5-00144feabdc0.html. [accessed 03 November 2015].
Ramos, A.R. 2012. The politics of perspectivism. Annual Review of Anthropology 41: 481-494.
Richards, P. 2005. The politics of gender, human rights, and being Indigenous in Chile. Gender and Society 19: 199-220.
Robertson, M.M. 2000. "No Net Loss": wetland restoration and the incomplete capitalization of nature. Antipode 32: 463-493.
Sandbrook, C. 2015. What is conservation? Oryx 49: 565-566.
Saxena, A.K., D. Chatti, K. Overstreet and M.R. Dove. 2018. From moral ecology to diverse ontologies: relational values in human ecological research, past and present. Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability 35: 54-60.
Singleton, B. 2016. Love-iathan, the meat-whale and hidden people: ordering Faroese pilot whaling. Journal of Political Ecology 23: 26-48.
Smith, N. 2007. Nature as accumulation strategy. Socialist Register (January): 1-36.
Smith, N. 2008. Neo-liberalism: dominant but dead. Focaal, European Journal of Anthropology 51: 155–157.
Smith, N. 2010. Uneven development (3rd edition). London; New York: Verso.
Spash, C.L. 2015. Bulldozing biodiversity: the economics of offsets and trading-in Nature. Biological Conservation 192: 541-551.
Sullivan, S. 2010. 'Ecosystem Service Commodities' - a new imperial ecology? Implications for animist immanent ecologies, with Deleuze and Guattari. New Formations 69:111-128.
Sullivan, S. 2013. Nature on the Move III:(Re) countenancing an animate nature. New Proposals 6(1-2): 50-71.
Sullivan, S. 2017. What's ontology got to do with it? On nature and knowledge in a political ecology of the 'green economy'. Journal of Political Ecology 24: 217-242.
Temper, L., D. Del Bene and J. Martinez-Alier. 2015. Mapping the frontiers and frontlines of Environmental Justice: The EJatlas. Journal of Political Ecology 22: 255-278.
Theriault, N. 2017. A forest of dreams: ontological multiplicity and the fantasies of environmental government in the Philippines. Political Geography 48: 114-127.
Trimedia. 2009. Lodge Hill: Stage Two Public Consultation - workshops feedback analysis. Currently not available online. Available upon request from the author.
Vaccaro, I., O. Beltran and P.A. Paquet. 2013. Political ecology and conservation policies: some theoretical genealogies. Journal of Political Ecology 20: 255-272.
Vidal, J. 2014. Conservationists split over 'biodiversity offsetting' plans. The Guardian 3 June. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2014/jun/03/conservationists-split-over-biodiversity-offsetting-plans, accessed 18/06/16.
Vigh, H.E. and D.B. Sausdal. 2014. From essence back to existence: anthropology beyond the ontological turn. Anthropological Theory 14: 49-73.
Viveiros de Castro, E. 1998. Cosmological deixis and Amerindian perspectivism. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute 4: 469-488.
Viveiros de Castro, E. 2004. Perspectival anthropology and the method of controlled equivocation. TipitÃ: Journal of the Society for the Anthropology of Lowland South America 2: 3-20.
Viveiros de Castro, E. 2015. Who is afraid of the ontological wolf? Some comments on an ongoing anthropological debate. The Cambridge Journal of Anthropology 33: 2-17.
West, P. 2005. Translation, value, and space: theorizing an ethnographic and engaged environmental anthropology. American Anthropologist 107(4): 632-642.
West, P. 2016. Dispossession and the environment: rhetoric and inequality in Papua New Guinea. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.
Willow, A. and S. Wylie. 2014. Politics, ecology, and the new anthropology of energy: exploring the emerging frontiers of hydraulic fracking. Journal of Political Ecology 21(12): 222-236.
Ανοιχτό συντονιστικό Θεσσαλονίκης ενάντια στα μετάλλεια χÏÏ…ÏƒÎ¿Ï 2012. Ενάντια στα Μεταλλεία ΧÏÏ…ÏƒÎ¿Ï [Against Gold Mining]. Θεσσαλονική [in Greek].
ΚÏκλος ΑναÏχικών. 1996. Η εξÎγεÏση των χωÏιών ΒαÏβάÏα και Ολυμπιάδα ενάντια στον εκσυχÏονισμό του θανάτου [The rebellion of Varvara and Olympiada villages against death by modernisation]. Athens [in Greek]. Available at https://www.anarxeio.gr/contents/view/h-ejegersh-ton-xorion-barbara-kai-olympiada-ena, accessed 29 Dec. 2018.
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.2458/v26i1.22014
Copyright (c) 2019 Dimitrios Bormpoudakis
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.